diff --git a/modules/builder.py b/modules/builder.py
index 736e4fc7..7e4defe0 100644
--- a/modules/builder.py
+++ b/modules/builder.py
@@ -1710,9 +1710,8 @@ class CollectionBuilder:
             if self.details["item_assets"] or overlay is not None:
                 try:
                     self.library.update_item_from_assets(item, overlay=overlay)
-                except UnidentifiedImageError:
-                    util.print_stacktrace()
-                    logger.error(f"Overlay Error: Overlay Failed for {item.title}")
+                except Failed as e:
+                    logger.error(e)
             self.library.edit_tags("label", item, add_tags=add_tags, remove_tags=remove_tags, sync_tags=sync_tags)
             if "item_radarr_tag" in self.item_details and item.ratingKey in self.library.movie_rating_key_map:
                 tmdb_ids.append(self.library.movie_rating_key_map[item.ratingKey])
diff --git a/modules/plex.py b/modules/plex.py
index f39b2845..f6045fef 100644
--- a/modules/plex.py
+++ b/modules/plex.py
@@ -459,7 +459,10 @@ class Plex:
             if self.config.Cache:
                 image, _, image_overlay = self.config.Cache.query_image_map(item.ratingKey, self.original_mapping_name, "poster")
             if poster_uploaded or not image_overlay or image_overlay != overlay_name:
-                og_image = requests.get(item.posterUrl).content
+                response = requests.get(item.posterUrl)
+                if response.status_code >= 400:
+                    raise Failed(f"Overlay Error: Overlay Failed for {item.title}")
+                og_image = response.content
                 with open(temp_image, "wb") as handler:
                     handler.write(og_image)
                 shutil.copyfile(temp_image, os.path.join(overlay_folder, f"{item.ratingKey}.png"))