diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Fresh.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Fresh.png
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8b2a324a
Binary files /dev/null and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Fresh.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Rotten.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Rotten.png
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..472c1957
Binary files /dev/null and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Rotten.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Top.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Top.png
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7aacc478
Binary files /dev/null and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Audience-Top.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Fresh.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Fresh.png
index 955e67da..847a79d1 100644
Binary files a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Fresh.png and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Fresh.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Rotten.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Rotten.png
index 4a72d100..e69bf510 100644
Binary files a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Rotten.png and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Rotten.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Top.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Top.png
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ad74c30c
Binary files /dev/null and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic-Top.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic.png b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic.png
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ad4bc7b4
Binary files /dev/null and b/defaults/overlays/images/rating/Critic.png differ
diff --git a/defaults/overlays/ratings.yml b/defaults/overlays/ratings.yml
index 5eed8058..49121d8e 100644
--- a/defaults/overlays/ratings.yml
+++ b/defaults/overlays/ratings.yml
@@ -162,6 +162,10 @@ templates:
             value: critic
           - rating3: [audience]
             value: audience
+      plex_all:
+        conditions:
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user]
+            value: <<plex_all>>
       mdblist_top:
         conditions:
           - image_level: Top
@@ -239,7 +243,7 @@ templates:
           - rating<<rating_num>>_image: star
             value: Star
           - rating<<rating_num>>_image: critic
-            value: Critic-
+            value: Critic
           - rating<<rating_num>>_image: audience
             value: Audience
       rating<<rating_num>>_horizontal_align:
@@ -514,22 +518,26 @@ templates:
         conditions:
           - image_level: Fresh
             value: <<fresh_rating>>
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [tmdb, imdb, trakt_user, omdb, mdb, mdb_average, mdb_imdb, mdb_metacritic, mdb_metacriticuser, mdb_trakt, mdb_tomatoes, mdb_tomatoesaudience, mdb_tmdb, mdb_letterboxd, mdb_myanimelist, anidb, anidb_average, anidb_score, mal]
+            value: <<gte>>
       lte:
         default: <<fresh_rating>>
         conditions:
           - image_level: Fresh
             value: <<maximum_rating>>
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [tmdb, imdb, trakt_user, omdb, mdb, mdb_average, mdb_imdb, mdb_metacritic, mdb_metacriticuser, mdb_trakt, mdb_tomatoes, mdb_tomatoesaudience, mdb_tmdb, mdb_letterboxd, mdb_myanimelist, anidb, anidb_average, anidb_score, mal]
+            value: <<lte>>
       gsuffix:
         conditions:
-          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user, tmdb, imdb, trakt_user, omdb, mdb, mdb_average, mdb_imdb, mdb_metacritic, mdb_metacriticuser, mdb_trakt, mdb_tomatoes, mdb_tomatoesaudience, mdb_tmdb, mdb_letterboxd, mdb_myanimelist, anidb, anidb_average, anidb_score, mal]
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user]
             image_level: [Fresh, Rotten]
             value: gte
       lsuffix:
         conditions:
-          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user, tmdb, imdb, trakt_user, omdb, mdb, mdb_average, mdb_imdb, mdb_metacritic, mdb_metacriticuser, mdb_trakt, mdb_tomatoes, mdb_tomatoesaudience, mdb_tmdb, mdb_letterboxd, mdb_myanimelist, anidb, anidb_average, anidb_score, mal]
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user]
             image_level: Fresh
             value: lte
-          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user, tmdb, imdb, trakt_user, omdb, mdb, mdb_average, mdb_imdb, mdb_metacritic, mdb_metacriticuser, mdb_trakt, mdb_tomatoes, mdb_tomatoesaudience, mdb_tmdb, mdb_letterboxd, mdb_myanimelist, anidb, anidb_average, anidb_score, mal]
+          - rating<<rating_num>>: [audience, critic, user]
             image_level: Rotten
             value: lt
       rating<<rating_num>>_default:
@@ -543,6 +551,7 @@ templates:
             rating<<rating_num>>_git.exists: false
             rating<<rating_num>>_repo.exists: false
             value: rating/<<rating<<rating_num>>_image_url>><<image_extra>>
+    plex_all: <<plex_all>
     plex_search:
       all:
         <<rating<<rating_num>>>>_rating.<<gsuffix>>: <<gte>>