diff --git a/CHANGELOG b/CHANGELOG
index 54c61427..5e51969f 100644
--- a/CHANGELOG
+++ b/CHANGELOG
@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ Fixes an issue where Prime Video overlays/collections would not be built when th
 
 # Bug Fixes
 Fixed the `cast` search option for the `imdb_search` builder
+Fixed an issue where season-level overlays would not work if the season had no image and the show-level image already had an overlay. As a result, episode overlays will now apply before season overlays, and season overlays will now apply before show overlays.
 Fixes #2258 `imdb_list` sort was not being parsed correctly
 Fixes `letterboxd_list` rating filter to use a 1-10 rating vs 1-100 to reflect how letterboxd ratings work on their website
 Fixed the `ids_to_anidb` lookup for anime movies and shows
diff --git a/modules/overlays.py b/modules/overlays.py
index a627b620..a8f295a0 100644
--- a/modules/overlays.py
+++ b/modules/overlays.py
@@ -82,7 +82,7 @@ class Overlays:
                     raise Failed
                 return _trakt_ratings
 
-            for i, (over_key, (item, over_names)) in enumerate(sorted(key_to_overlays.items(), key=lambda io: self.library.get_item_sort_title(io[1][0])), 1):
+            for i, (over_key, (item, over_names)) in enumerate(sorted(key_to_overlays.items(), key=lambda io: self.library.get_item_sort_title(io[1][0], ep_first_order=True)), 1):
                 item_title = self.library.get_item_sort_title(item, atr="title")
                 try:
                     logger.ghost(f"Overlaying: {i}/{len(key_to_overlays)} {item_title}")
diff --git a/modules/plex.py b/modules/plex.py
index d5e4a560..3b0d45bd 100644
--- a/modules/plex.py
+++ b/modules/plex.py
@@ -1640,15 +1640,17 @@ class Plex(Library):
 
         return map_key, attrs
 
-    def get_item_sort_title(self, item_to_sort, atr="titleSort"):
+
+    def get_item_sort_title(self, item_to_sort, atr="titleSort", ep_first_order=False):
         if isinstance(item_to_sort, Album):
-            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.artist(), atr)} Album {getattr(item_to_sort, atr)}"
+            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.artist(), atr)}{'1' if ep_first_order else ''} Album {getattr(item_to_sort, atr)}"
         elif isinstance(item_to_sort, Season):
-            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.show(), atr)} Season {item_to_sort.seasonNumber}"
+            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.show(), atr)}{'1' if ep_first_order else ''} Season {item_to_sort.seasonNumber}"
         elif isinstance(item_to_sort, Episode):
-            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.show(), atr)} {item_to_sort.seasonEpisode.upper()}"
+            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort.show(), atr)}{'0' if ep_first_order else ''} {item_to_sort.seasonEpisode.upper()}"
         else:
-            return getattr(item_to_sort, atr)
+            return f"{getattr(item_to_sort, atr)}{'2' if ep_first_order else ''}"
+
 
     def split(self, text):
         attribute, modifier = os.path.splitext(str(text).lower())